More…

When East of Eden (1952), in vintage Pan paperback came into the Op Shop, it was a sign that I needed to read Steinbeck‘s 3rd great novel (joining Of Mice and Men, and The Grapes of Wrath). It took me awhile, but it was terrific. I never quite knew exactly where it was going, and I wrongly assumed that the Charles and Adam of the first part of the book would become the Cain and Abel alluded to in some summaries.

I’ve read criticism that Cathy/Kate is too exaggeratedly evil and irredeemable, and I get it, but every book needs a foil for the generous and human instincts of a saint-like figure like Lee, the Chinese housekeeper and defacto parent.

The turbulent and wrought lives of, in particular, father Adam, but also the young girl Abra were magnificently rendered. Cal, the man seemingly predestined to follow the path of his mother seesawed between hopelessness and appreciation for what had been granted to him. The final bedside scene was every bit as dramatic and poignant as I had found the one in Grapes. 4.5 stars.

Fanny Hill (1749) by John Cleland was in a nice vintage paperback, and I was all onboard, until I read it to completion. The trickery with which an innocent rustic is induced to exhibit her charms and the bidding frenzy for her maidenhead were very convincing. After the fourth of fifth time that she was made the private indulgence of a wealthy benefactor, the story became a bit tiresome. She ended up as sole inheritor of an elderly gentleman who passed, and was able to reacquaint herself with her original lover, and it all ended happily thereafter. 3.5 stars.

Slow Burner (1958), my second book by William Haggard had a similar governmental / ministerial setting to the first, but was duller on the whole in comparison. Haggard really excels in describing fusty professional rivalries and petty jealousy, but the crime aspects are not as convincing. In this case, a UK developed new source of cheap energy had seemingly been duplicated and was stored in a suburban house whilst being shopped to foreign interests, and no one knew who the inner-circle betrayer was. It took a leap for me to accept the motivations and desperation amongst those clamoring to solve the case. 3.5 stars.

I did not think Mill on the Floss by George Elliot was a very successful book, and in many ways it was as dull as the title. I enjoyed the characterisation of the families and their internal bickerings, but Maggie’s strongly held brotherly promises of childhood and her moral romantic dilemmas were overly long and repetitive. The out-of-nowhere tragic ending was hurried and tokenistic and had me seeking an explanation, so I read the Introduction by A.S.Byatt and found it too cerebral and unhelpful. The girl was in a terrible predicament, and yet she also felt she couldn’t leave the town and begin a new life. In today’s world, she would be encouraged to go ahead and do all the things she thought she couldn’t, and seek forgiveness afterwards, which is what Elliot suggests would be more palatable to her social peers at the time anyway. 3 stars.

Shirley (2023, and the name of a house), by the hip sounding Ronnie Scott (an Australian male btw), is a Collingwood/Fitzroy based coming-of-COVID novel about a woman struggling to gain independence from the legacy of her famous estranged mother and her various personal assistants. There was bleakness that reminded me of Mossfegh, which gradually overwhelmed the clever, inventive writing and the very believable female characterisation. By the last third I just wanted it to be over, despite a really promising first half. And I never want to read about Meany the unwell cat, or David her ex boyfriend again! 3 stars.

I absolutely loved Creation Lake (2024) by Rachel Kushner, or at least the first 2/3rd of it. With a fun premise: a female secret agent is paid to infiltrate a leftist anti-government commune and get them to commit illegalities by whatever means. I found it a page turner, nicely paced and peppered with facts about Neanderthals(!) and general musings about the benefits of isolation via snooped emails from the cult’s Luddite founder Bruno. The end was maybe a bit improbable, but still satisfying – beautifully executed: 4 stars.

Before Allan threw them into the Recycle bin at Sacred Heart, I knabbed an intriguing trio of banged up Penguin books by Gabriel Chevallier about a fictional provincial village in Beaujolais called Clochemerle (1936). This one was the first in the series. Apparently now an adjective describing “petty parochial squabbling”, it was surprisingly bawdy and intriguing. The mayor decides as a sign of civility and progressiveness, that a public urinal be funded and suitably located in the centre of a tiny village, against a church wall. The tension builds between the religious and the not so, and things escalate to the point where the army is brought in and it goes to the highest level of government. I felt like it tapered off a little, but all ends were nicely tied up. Many postulations as to the natures of men and women which make it dated and amusing now. 3.5 stars.

I always wanted to know what Guiseppe Garibaldi did, and when he lived, and finally I got my chance. The Lion of Caprera (1962) by John Parris, fairly dryly outlines the passionate life of “the father of italy” – a young sailor who in the 1840s and 50s embraced the nationalist cause of a single Italy, madly recruited redshirts and progressively overthrew the Austrians, the French and the Neopolitans. His often naive, energetic style and his progressive politics won him many followers and made him a legendary figure with those under the yoke of regional prime ministers and the pope himself. The book took great delight in summarising his indiscretions with whatever young peasant girl caught his eye, and he had quite a handful of illegitimate children, many of whom died young. The politics of the period were well outlined, and pretty much everyone in power anywhere despised him and his rabid following, and were determined to not let him take credit for any victory or territorial gain – giving him the oldest, worst weaponry, and actively trying to have him be ambushed as he “knew too much”. The scheming Cavour was incredibly unhelpful, and it was unfortunate he died before full reunifcation of Italy was achieved, as it would have been such a blow! 3 stars.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.